F

Montauk Renewables, Inc. — Earnings Quality Grade F

MNTK · Basic Materials

Major red flags

Revenue
$176M
2025
Net Income
$2M
2025
Gross Margin
37.3%
Free Cash Flow
-$86M
01

Screening Summary

9
Passed
4
Watch
4
Failed
-2.96
M-Score

Management Signals

No recent CEO, CFO, board, or accounting leadership signals found in SEC 8-K filings.
02

Financial Trends

Revenue & Net Income ($B)

Margins (%)

03

18-Point Screening

01

Revenue Quality

A1DSO Change

DSO 14 days, change -3 days YoY

A2AR vs Revenue Growth

AR growth -16.4% vs revenue growth 0.4%

A3Revenue vs CFFO

Revenue 0.4%, CFFO -30.7%. Cash follows revenue

02

Expense Quality

B1Inventory vs COGS

No material inventory

!
B2CapEx vs Revenue

CapEx growth 87.0% is >2x revenue growth 0.4%

B3SG&A Ratio

SG&A/Gross Profit = 48.2%. Normal

!
B4Gross Margin

Gross margin swung -6.8pp (44.1% → 37.3%)

03

Cash Flow Quality

!
C1CFFO vs Net Income

CFFO far exceeds NI (ratio 17.4x). Non-cash charges depressing profits

C2Free Cash Flow

FCF < 50% of Net Income for 3 years

C3Accruals Ratio

Accruals ratio = -6.6%. Low accruals

C4Cash vs Debt

Cash $0.0B covers only 17% of debt $0.1B

04

Balance Sheet Health

D1Goodwill + Intangibles

Goodwill+Intangibles $0.0B = 7% of equity. Manageable

D2Leverage

Debt/EBITDA = 4.3x (>4x). Interest coverage = 0.8x (<2x). Financial stress

!
D3Soft Asset Growth

Other assets grew 48.7% vs revenue 0.4%

D4Asset Impairment

No write-off data

05

Acquisition Risk

E1Serial Acquirer FCF

FCF after acquisitions negative for 3 years

Small-cap context: A single acquisition on a small balance sheet can trip serial-acquirer logic.

E2Goodwill Surge

Goodwill+Intangibles change 8% YoY. Normal

06

Manipulation Score

F1Beneish M-Score

M-Score = -2.96 (< -2.22). Unlikely manipulator

Portfolio monitoring

Monitor MNTK continuously

The full checks and model details are free to read. Use Watchlist to track your holdings; Pro adds automatic quarterly rescoring, risk-event email alerts, scans up to 50 tickers, and export workflows.

04

Beneish M-Score

Manipulation Probability-2.96
-4.0 Clean-2.22 Grey-1.78 Danger0
0.833
DSRI
AR growing faster than revenue?
1.183
GMI
Gross margin declining?
1.185
AQI
Asset quality deteriorating?
1.004
SGI
Revenue growth rate
1
DEPI
Depreciation slowing?
0.871
SGAI
SG&A ratio changing?
-0.0656
TATA
Accruals level
1.653
LVGI
Leverage increasing?
05

Altman Z-Score

2.12
Grey Zone
0 Distress1.102.605.0+ Safe
0.0086
Liquidity
0.1311
Cumulative profit
0.0053
Operating efficiency
1.5272
Leverage

Generated from public financial data using forensic accounting frameworks. Not investment advice. Data: Yahoo Finance · 2026-04-25